SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Finding Help with Programming Errors: An Exploratory Study
of Novice Software Engineers’ Focus in Stack Overflow Posts
Preetha Chatterjee Minji Kong Lori Pollock
Journal of Systems and Software (JSS), Volume 159, Jan 2020
Asst. Prof.
[Fall ’21]
Ph.D.
Stack Overflow Usage: Statistics and Challenges
40% participants are novice programmers (< 5 yrs experience)
who struggle to find relevant information from a Stack Overflow post!!
Information Overload:
The top 5 Stack Overflow
questions for a sample
query “Differences
Hashmap Hashtable Java”,
consist of 51 answers
which have 6,771 words in
total [Xu et. al. 2017]
https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2020
We aim to understand:
How novice software engineers direct their efforts and what kinds of
information they focus on within a Stack Overflow post
Study Design
RQ1. Challenges - What slows a
novice software engineer down in
identifying the solution most
appropriate for their problem?
RQ2. Focus - Which parts of a post
novice software engineers focus on to
reduce their time in locating
information?
RQ1 Findings: Developer Challenges
Survey
Question
69% participants indicated “Too much text containing unnecessary details”
51% participants indicated “Determining embedded code segment relevance”
39% indicated “Too much code containing unnecessary details”
Question Title: Polymorphism in Java error: cannot find Symbol
I've just started learning object oriented programming from the book head first java.
It said that polymorphism enables me to create an array of the superclass type and
then have all the subclasses as the array elements.
But when I tried writing code using the same principles it ran into error saying error:
cannot find symbol I made the classes the superclass was animal and the dog class
extended the animal class having a fetch method of its own, but when I referenced
the dog variable as animal it did not work here is the code
…
The error
tester.java:4: error: cannot find symbol doggie.fetch();
symbol: method fetch()
location: variable doggie of type animal
When using polymorphism, if you create an instance of the subclass and store its
reference in a variable of superclass type, you can only call those methods on the
newly created instance which are present in the super class.
In your code, you created an instance of dog class and stored its reference
in doggie which is of type animal (super class of dog), In such case, you can't call any
method on dog class instance that isn't available in animal class. fetch method is not
defined in the animal class hence you get the error.
Either define the fetch method in the animal class
OR Change animal doggie = new dog(); to dog doggie = new dog();
Developer’s Goal
Developer’s Pertinent
Action
System Symptom
Accepted Answer
Symptom Cause
Posted Solution
Solution Justification
RQ2 Findings: Developer Focus
• Too much text including unnecessary
details (69%)
• Determining embedded code segment
relevance (51%)
• Too much code including unnecessary
details (39%)
Developer’s Goal
Developer’s Pertinent Action
System Symptom
Symptom Cause
Posted Solution
Solution Justification
Novice software engineers pay attention to only 27% code and 15-21% of text in a SO post!
@PreethaChatterj
preethac@udel.edu sites.udel.edu/preethac/
Significance:
 improve the Q&A forum interface
 guide tools for mining forums
 improve granularity of traceability mappings involving forum posts
Paper link: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2019.110454
Summary and Overview
RQ1. Challenges - What slows a
novice software engineer down in
identifying the solution most
appropriate for their problem?
RQ2. Focus - Which parts of a post
novice software engineers focus on to
reduce their time in locating
information?
Ad

Recommended

Mining Code Examples with Descriptive Text from Software Artifacts
Mining Code Examples with Descriptive Text from Software Artifacts
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Extracting Archival-Quality Information from Software-Related Chats
Extracting Archival-Quality Information from Software-Related Chats
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Exploratory Study of Slack Q&A Chats as a Mining Source for Software Engineer...
Exploratory Study of Slack Q&A Chats as a Mining Source for Software Engineer...
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Proactive Empirical Assessment of New Language Feature Adoption via Automated...
Proactive Empirical Assessment of New Language Feature Adoption via Automated...
Raffi Khatchadourian
 
PyCon 2013 - Experiments in data mining, entity disambiguation and how to thi...
PyCon 2013 - Experiments in data mining, entity disambiguation and how to thi...
Ekta Grover
 
Natural Language Processing using Java
Natural Language Processing using Java
Sangameswar Venkatraman
 
GPT-2: Language Models are Unsupervised Multitask Learners
GPT-2: Language Models are Unsupervised Multitask Learners
Young Seok Kim
 
QALL-ME: Ontology and Semantic Web
QALL-ME: Ontology and Semantic Web
Constantin Orasan
 
A Hierarchical Model of Reviews for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
A Hierarchical Model of Reviews for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
Sebastian Ruder
 
Building a Dynamic Bidding system for a location based Display advertising Pl...
Building a Dynamic Bidding system for a location based Display advertising Pl...
Ekta Grover
 
Summarization Techniques for Code, Changes, and Testing
Summarization Techniques for Code, Changes, and Testing
Sebastiano Panichella
 
Extracting keywords from texts - Sanda Martincic Ipsic
Extracting keywords from texts - Sanda Martincic Ipsic
Institute of Contemporary Sciences
 
Supporting program comprehension with source code summarization
Supporting program comprehension with source code summarization
Masud Rahman
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
IJERD Editor
 
Intro to programing with java-lecture 1
Intro to programing with java-lecture 1
Mohamed Essam
 
Improving VIVO search through semantic ranking.
Improving VIVO search through semantic ranking.
Deepak K
 
Illustrated Code (ASE 2021)
Illustrated Code (ASE 2021)
CISPA Helmholtz Center for Information Security
 
Understanding Log Lines using Development Knowledge
Understanding Log Lines using Development Knowledge
SAIL_QU
 
Mining Stack Overflow to Tun the IDE into a Self-confident Programming Prompter
Mining Stack Overflow to Tun the IDE into a Self-confident Programming Prompter
Luca Ponzanelli
 
HotSoS16 Tutorial "Text Analytics for Security" by Tao Xie and William Enck
HotSoS16 Tutorial "Text Analytics for Security" by Tao Xie and William Enck
Tao Xie
 
Can Deep Learning solve the Sentiment Analysis Problem
Can Deep Learning solve the Sentiment Analysis Problem
Mark Cieliebak
 
Sentiment analyzer and opinion mining
Sentiment analyzer and opinion mining
Ankush Mehta
 
2. introduction to compiler
2. introduction to compiler
Saeed Parsa
 
DRONE: A Tool to Detect and Repair Directive Defects in Java APIs Documentation
DRONE: A Tool to Detect and Repair Directive Defects in Java APIs Documentation
Sebastiano Panichella
 
Is Text Search an Effective Approach for Fault Localization: A Practitioners ...
Is Text Search an Effective Approach for Fault Localization: A Practitioners ...
Debdoot Mukherjee
 
On the Distribution of Test Smells in Open Source Android Applications: An Ex...
On the Distribution of Test Smells in Open Source Android Applications: An Ex...
University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa
 
Semantic & Multilingual Strategies in Lucene/Solr
Semantic & Multilingual Strategies in Lucene/Solr
Trey Grainger
 
Vivo Search
Vivo Search
Anup Sawant
 
Automatic Identification of Informative Code in Stack Overflow Posts
Automatic Identification of Informative Code in Stack Overflow Posts
Preetha Chatterjee
 
The Java Learning Kit Chapter 5 – Methods and Modular.docx
The Java Learning Kit Chapter 5 – Methods and Modular.docx
arnoldmeredith47041
 

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

A Hierarchical Model of Reviews for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
A Hierarchical Model of Reviews for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
Sebastian Ruder
 
Building a Dynamic Bidding system for a location based Display advertising Pl...
Building a Dynamic Bidding system for a location based Display advertising Pl...
Ekta Grover
 
Summarization Techniques for Code, Changes, and Testing
Summarization Techniques for Code, Changes, and Testing
Sebastiano Panichella
 
Extracting keywords from texts - Sanda Martincic Ipsic
Extracting keywords from texts - Sanda Martincic Ipsic
Institute of Contemporary Sciences
 
Supporting program comprehension with source code summarization
Supporting program comprehension with source code summarization
Masud Rahman
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
IJERD Editor
 
Intro to programing with java-lecture 1
Intro to programing with java-lecture 1
Mohamed Essam
 
Improving VIVO search through semantic ranking.
Improving VIVO search through semantic ranking.
Deepak K
 
Illustrated Code (ASE 2021)
Illustrated Code (ASE 2021)
CISPA Helmholtz Center for Information Security
 
Understanding Log Lines using Development Knowledge
Understanding Log Lines using Development Knowledge
SAIL_QU
 
Mining Stack Overflow to Tun the IDE into a Self-confident Programming Prompter
Mining Stack Overflow to Tun the IDE into a Self-confident Programming Prompter
Luca Ponzanelli
 
HotSoS16 Tutorial "Text Analytics for Security" by Tao Xie and William Enck
HotSoS16 Tutorial "Text Analytics for Security" by Tao Xie and William Enck
Tao Xie
 
Can Deep Learning solve the Sentiment Analysis Problem
Can Deep Learning solve the Sentiment Analysis Problem
Mark Cieliebak
 
Sentiment analyzer and opinion mining
Sentiment analyzer and opinion mining
Ankush Mehta
 
2. introduction to compiler
2. introduction to compiler
Saeed Parsa
 
DRONE: A Tool to Detect and Repair Directive Defects in Java APIs Documentation
DRONE: A Tool to Detect and Repair Directive Defects in Java APIs Documentation
Sebastiano Panichella
 
Is Text Search an Effective Approach for Fault Localization: A Practitioners ...
Is Text Search an Effective Approach for Fault Localization: A Practitioners ...
Debdoot Mukherjee
 
On the Distribution of Test Smells in Open Source Android Applications: An Ex...
On the Distribution of Test Smells in Open Source Android Applications: An Ex...
University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa
 
Semantic & Multilingual Strategies in Lucene/Solr
Semantic & Multilingual Strategies in Lucene/Solr
Trey Grainger
 
Vivo Search
Vivo Search
Anup Sawant
 
A Hierarchical Model of Reviews for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
A Hierarchical Model of Reviews for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
Sebastian Ruder
 
Building a Dynamic Bidding system for a location based Display advertising Pl...
Building a Dynamic Bidding system for a location based Display advertising Pl...
Ekta Grover
 
Summarization Techniques for Code, Changes, and Testing
Summarization Techniques for Code, Changes, and Testing
Sebastiano Panichella
 
Supporting program comprehension with source code summarization
Supporting program comprehension with source code summarization
Masud Rahman
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
IJERD Editor
 
Intro to programing with java-lecture 1
Intro to programing with java-lecture 1
Mohamed Essam
 
Improving VIVO search through semantic ranking.
Improving VIVO search through semantic ranking.
Deepak K
 
Understanding Log Lines using Development Knowledge
Understanding Log Lines using Development Knowledge
SAIL_QU
 
Mining Stack Overflow to Tun the IDE into a Self-confident Programming Prompter
Mining Stack Overflow to Tun the IDE into a Self-confident Programming Prompter
Luca Ponzanelli
 
HotSoS16 Tutorial "Text Analytics for Security" by Tao Xie and William Enck
HotSoS16 Tutorial "Text Analytics for Security" by Tao Xie and William Enck
Tao Xie
 
Can Deep Learning solve the Sentiment Analysis Problem
Can Deep Learning solve the Sentiment Analysis Problem
Mark Cieliebak
 
Sentiment analyzer and opinion mining
Sentiment analyzer and opinion mining
Ankush Mehta
 
2. introduction to compiler
2. introduction to compiler
Saeed Parsa
 
DRONE: A Tool to Detect and Repair Directive Defects in Java APIs Documentation
DRONE: A Tool to Detect and Repair Directive Defects in Java APIs Documentation
Sebastiano Panichella
 
Is Text Search an Effective Approach for Fault Localization: A Practitioners ...
Is Text Search an Effective Approach for Fault Localization: A Practitioners ...
Debdoot Mukherjee
 
On the Distribution of Test Smells in Open Source Android Applications: An Ex...
On the Distribution of Test Smells in Open Source Android Applications: An Ex...
University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa
 
Semantic & Multilingual Strategies in Lucene/Solr
Semantic & Multilingual Strategies in Lucene/Solr
Trey Grainger
 

Similar to Finding Help with Programming Errors: An Exploratory Study of Novice Software Engineers’ Focus in Stack Overflow Posts (20)

Automatic Identification of Informative Code in Stack Overflow Posts
Automatic Identification of Informative Code in Stack Overflow Posts
Preetha Chatterjee
 
The Java Learning Kit Chapter 5 – Methods and Modular.docx
The Java Learning Kit Chapter 5 – Methods and Modular.docx
arnoldmeredith47041
 
25 php interview questions – codementor
25 php interview questions – codementor
Arc & Codementor
 
Ch 6 only 1. Distinguish between a purpose statement, research p
Ch 6 only 1. Distinguish between a purpose statement, research p
MaximaSheffield592
 
Ch 6 only 1. distinguish between a purpose statement, research p
Ch 6 only 1. distinguish between a purpose statement, research p
nand15
 
Object Oriented Programming Lab Manual
Object Oriented Programming Lab Manual
Abdul Hannan
 
Roman Sevastyanov "Рефакторинг - пути улучшения кода"
Roman Sevastyanov "Рефакторинг - пути улучшения кода"
Fwdays
 
Infosys Interview Questions By ScholarHat
Infosys Interview Questions By ScholarHat
Scholarhat
 
QUESTION ANALYSIS FOR ARABIC QUESTION ANSWERING SYSTEMS
QUESTION ANALYSIS FOR ARABIC QUESTION ANSWERING SYSTEMS
ijnlc
 
Search Solutions 2015: Towards a new model of search relevance testing
Search Solutions 2015: Towards a new model of search relevance testing
Charlie Hull
 
Cser13.ppt
Cser13.ppt
Yann-Gaël Guéhéneuc
 
Few minutes To better Code - Refactoring
Few minutes To better Code - Refactoring
Diaa Al-Salehi
 
IRJET- Semantic Question Matching
IRJET- Semantic Question Matching
IRJET Journal
 
Accelerate the ROI of PHP in your Enterprise
Accelerate the ROI of PHP in your Enterprise
Enterprise PHP Center
 
Best Practices for Building Successful LLM Applications
Best Practices for Building Successful LLM Applications
BhavulGauri1
 
Code review
Code review
Aleksey Solntsev
 
Reduce Reuse Refactor
Reduce Reuse Refactor
Alena Holligan
 
Turning AI Challenges into Learning Opportunities: Empowering Students to Use...
Turning AI Challenges into Learning Opportunities: Empowering Students to Use...
SEDA
 
Getting Unstuck: Working with Legacy Code and Data
Getting Unstuck: Working with Legacy Code and Data
Cory Foy
 
Sanjay resume
Sanjay resume
Sanjay Kumar
 
Automatic Identification of Informative Code in Stack Overflow Posts
Automatic Identification of Informative Code in Stack Overflow Posts
Preetha Chatterjee
 
The Java Learning Kit Chapter 5 – Methods and Modular.docx
The Java Learning Kit Chapter 5 – Methods and Modular.docx
arnoldmeredith47041
 
25 php interview questions – codementor
25 php interview questions – codementor
Arc & Codementor
 
Ch 6 only 1. Distinguish between a purpose statement, research p
Ch 6 only 1. Distinguish between a purpose statement, research p
MaximaSheffield592
 
Ch 6 only 1. distinguish between a purpose statement, research p
Ch 6 only 1. distinguish between a purpose statement, research p
nand15
 
Object Oriented Programming Lab Manual
Object Oriented Programming Lab Manual
Abdul Hannan
 
Roman Sevastyanov "Рефакторинг - пути улучшения кода"
Roman Sevastyanov "Рефакторинг - пути улучшения кода"
Fwdays
 
Infosys Interview Questions By ScholarHat
Infosys Interview Questions By ScholarHat
Scholarhat
 
QUESTION ANALYSIS FOR ARABIC QUESTION ANSWERING SYSTEMS
QUESTION ANALYSIS FOR ARABIC QUESTION ANSWERING SYSTEMS
ijnlc
 
Search Solutions 2015: Towards a new model of search relevance testing
Search Solutions 2015: Towards a new model of search relevance testing
Charlie Hull
 
Few minutes To better Code - Refactoring
Few minutes To better Code - Refactoring
Diaa Al-Salehi
 
IRJET- Semantic Question Matching
IRJET- Semantic Question Matching
IRJET Journal
 
Accelerate the ROI of PHP in your Enterprise
Accelerate the ROI of PHP in your Enterprise
Enterprise PHP Center
 
Best Practices for Building Successful LLM Applications
Best Practices for Building Successful LLM Applications
BhavulGauri1
 
Turning AI Challenges into Learning Opportunities: Empowering Students to Use...
Turning AI Challenges into Learning Opportunities: Empowering Students to Use...
SEDA
 
Getting Unstuck: Working with Legacy Code and Data
Getting Unstuck: Working with Legacy Code and Data
Cory Foy
 
Ad

More from Preetha Chatterjee (6)

Incivility in Open Source Projects: A Comprehensive Annotated Dataset of Lock...
Incivility in Open Source Projects: A Comprehensive Annotated Dataset of Lock...
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Exploring ChatGPT for Toxicity Detection in GitHub
Exploring ChatGPT for Toxicity Detection in GitHub
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Interpersonal Trust in OSS: Exploring Dimensions of Trust in GitHub Pull Requ...
Interpersonal Trust in OSS: Exploring Dimensions of Trust in GitHub Pull Requ...
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Data Augmentation for Improving Emotion Recognition in Software Engineering C...
Data Augmentation for Improving Emotion Recognition in Software Engineering C...
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Automatically Identifying the Quality of Developer Chats for Post Hoc Use
Automatically Identifying the Quality of Developer Chats for Post Hoc Use
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Extracting Code Segments and Their Descriptions from Research Articles
Extracting Code Segments and Their Descriptions from Research Articles
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Incivility in Open Source Projects: A Comprehensive Annotated Dataset of Lock...
Incivility in Open Source Projects: A Comprehensive Annotated Dataset of Lock...
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Exploring ChatGPT for Toxicity Detection in GitHub
Exploring ChatGPT for Toxicity Detection in GitHub
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Interpersonal Trust in OSS: Exploring Dimensions of Trust in GitHub Pull Requ...
Interpersonal Trust in OSS: Exploring Dimensions of Trust in GitHub Pull Requ...
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Data Augmentation for Improving Emotion Recognition in Software Engineering C...
Data Augmentation for Improving Emotion Recognition in Software Engineering C...
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Automatically Identifying the Quality of Developer Chats for Post Hoc Use
Automatically Identifying the Quality of Developer Chats for Post Hoc Use
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Extracting Code Segments and Their Descriptions from Research Articles
Extracting Code Segments and Their Descriptions from Research Articles
Preetha Chatterjee
 
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

M&A5 Q1 1 differentiate evolving early Philippine conventional and contempora...
M&A5 Q1 1 differentiate evolving early Philippine conventional and contempora...
ErlizaRosete
 
Vitamin and Nutritional Deficiencies.pptx
Vitamin and Nutritional Deficiencies.pptx
Vishal Chanalia
 
ENGLISH-5 Q1 Lesson 1.pptx - Story Elements
ENGLISH-5 Q1 Lesson 1.pptx - Story Elements
Mayvel Nadal
 
Pests of Maize: An comprehensive overview.pptx
Pests of Maize: An comprehensive overview.pptx
Arshad Shaikh
 
NSUMD_M1 Library Orientation_June 11, 2025.pptx
NSUMD_M1 Library Orientation_June 11, 2025.pptx
Julie Sarpy
 
Public Health For The 21st Century 1st Edition Judy Orme Jane Powell
Public Health For The 21st Century 1st Edition Judy Orme Jane Powell
trjnesjnqg7801
 
How to Customize Quotation Layouts in Odoo 18
How to Customize Quotation Layouts in Odoo 18
Celine George
 
How to use search fetch method in Odoo 18
How to use search fetch method in Odoo 18
Celine George
 
VCE Literature Section A Exam Response Guide
VCE Literature Section A Exam Response Guide
jpinnuck
 
Paper 107 | From Watchdog to Lapdog: Ishiguro’s Fiction and the Rise of “Godi...
Paper 107 | From Watchdog to Lapdog: Ishiguro’s Fiction and the Rise of “Godi...
Rajdeep Bavaliya
 
IIT KGP Quiz Week 2024 Sports Quiz (Prelims + Finals)
IIT KGP Quiz Week 2024 Sports Quiz (Prelims + Finals)
IIT Kharagpur Quiz Club
 
GREAT QUIZ EXCHANGE 2025 - GENERAL QUIZ.pptx
GREAT QUIZ EXCHANGE 2025 - GENERAL QUIZ.pptx
Ronisha Das
 
F-BLOCK ELEMENTS POWER POINT PRESENTATIONS
F-BLOCK ELEMENTS POWER POINT PRESENTATIONS
mprpgcwa2024
 
Photo chemistry Power Point Presentation
Photo chemistry Power Point Presentation
mprpgcwa2024
 
Q1_ENGLISH_PPT_WEEK 1 power point grade 3 Quarter 1 week 1
Q1_ENGLISH_PPT_WEEK 1 power point grade 3 Quarter 1 week 1
jutaydeonne
 
List View Components in Odoo 18 - Odoo Slides
List View Components in Odoo 18 - Odoo Slides
Celine George
 
Gladiolous Cultivation practices by AKL.pdf
Gladiolous Cultivation practices by AKL.pdf
kushallamichhame
 
Aprendendo Arquitetura Framework Salesforce - Dia 02
Aprendendo Arquitetura Framework Salesforce - Dia 02
Mauricio Alexandre Silva
 
INDUCTIVE EFFECT slide for first prof pharamacy students
INDUCTIVE EFFECT slide for first prof pharamacy students
SHABNAM FAIZ
 
Tanja Vujicic - PISA for Schools contact Info
Tanja Vujicic - PISA for Schools contact Info
EduSkills OECD
 
M&A5 Q1 1 differentiate evolving early Philippine conventional and contempora...
M&A5 Q1 1 differentiate evolving early Philippine conventional and contempora...
ErlizaRosete
 
Vitamin and Nutritional Deficiencies.pptx
Vitamin and Nutritional Deficiencies.pptx
Vishal Chanalia
 
ENGLISH-5 Q1 Lesson 1.pptx - Story Elements
ENGLISH-5 Q1 Lesson 1.pptx - Story Elements
Mayvel Nadal
 
Pests of Maize: An comprehensive overview.pptx
Pests of Maize: An comprehensive overview.pptx
Arshad Shaikh
 
NSUMD_M1 Library Orientation_June 11, 2025.pptx
NSUMD_M1 Library Orientation_June 11, 2025.pptx
Julie Sarpy
 
Public Health For The 21st Century 1st Edition Judy Orme Jane Powell
Public Health For The 21st Century 1st Edition Judy Orme Jane Powell
trjnesjnqg7801
 
How to Customize Quotation Layouts in Odoo 18
How to Customize Quotation Layouts in Odoo 18
Celine George
 
How to use search fetch method in Odoo 18
How to use search fetch method in Odoo 18
Celine George
 
VCE Literature Section A Exam Response Guide
VCE Literature Section A Exam Response Guide
jpinnuck
 
Paper 107 | From Watchdog to Lapdog: Ishiguro’s Fiction and the Rise of “Godi...
Paper 107 | From Watchdog to Lapdog: Ishiguro’s Fiction and the Rise of “Godi...
Rajdeep Bavaliya
 
IIT KGP Quiz Week 2024 Sports Quiz (Prelims + Finals)
IIT KGP Quiz Week 2024 Sports Quiz (Prelims + Finals)
IIT Kharagpur Quiz Club
 
GREAT QUIZ EXCHANGE 2025 - GENERAL QUIZ.pptx
GREAT QUIZ EXCHANGE 2025 - GENERAL QUIZ.pptx
Ronisha Das
 
F-BLOCK ELEMENTS POWER POINT PRESENTATIONS
F-BLOCK ELEMENTS POWER POINT PRESENTATIONS
mprpgcwa2024
 
Photo chemistry Power Point Presentation
Photo chemistry Power Point Presentation
mprpgcwa2024
 
Q1_ENGLISH_PPT_WEEK 1 power point grade 3 Quarter 1 week 1
Q1_ENGLISH_PPT_WEEK 1 power point grade 3 Quarter 1 week 1
jutaydeonne
 
List View Components in Odoo 18 - Odoo Slides
List View Components in Odoo 18 - Odoo Slides
Celine George
 
Gladiolous Cultivation practices by AKL.pdf
Gladiolous Cultivation practices by AKL.pdf
kushallamichhame
 
Aprendendo Arquitetura Framework Salesforce - Dia 02
Aprendendo Arquitetura Framework Salesforce - Dia 02
Mauricio Alexandre Silva
 
INDUCTIVE EFFECT slide for first prof pharamacy students
INDUCTIVE EFFECT slide for first prof pharamacy students
SHABNAM FAIZ
 
Tanja Vujicic - PISA for Schools contact Info
Tanja Vujicic - PISA for Schools contact Info
EduSkills OECD
 

Finding Help with Programming Errors: An Exploratory Study of Novice Software Engineers’ Focus in Stack Overflow Posts

  • 1. Finding Help with Programming Errors: An Exploratory Study of Novice Software Engineers’ Focus in Stack Overflow Posts Preetha Chatterjee Minji Kong Lori Pollock Journal of Systems and Software (JSS), Volume 159, Jan 2020 Asst. Prof. [Fall ’21] Ph.D.
  • 2. Stack Overflow Usage: Statistics and Challenges 40% participants are novice programmers (< 5 yrs experience) who struggle to find relevant information from a Stack Overflow post!! Information Overload: The top 5 Stack Overflow questions for a sample query “Differences Hashmap Hashtable Java”, consist of 51 answers which have 6,771 words in total [Xu et. al. 2017] https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2020 We aim to understand: How novice software engineers direct their efforts and what kinds of information they focus on within a Stack Overflow post
  • 3. Study Design RQ1. Challenges - What slows a novice software engineer down in identifying the solution most appropriate for their problem? RQ2. Focus - Which parts of a post novice software engineers focus on to reduce their time in locating information?
  • 4. RQ1 Findings: Developer Challenges Survey Question 69% participants indicated “Too much text containing unnecessary details” 51% participants indicated “Determining embedded code segment relevance” 39% indicated “Too much code containing unnecessary details”
  • 5. Question Title: Polymorphism in Java error: cannot find Symbol I've just started learning object oriented programming from the book head first java. It said that polymorphism enables me to create an array of the superclass type and then have all the subclasses as the array elements. But when I tried writing code using the same principles it ran into error saying error: cannot find symbol I made the classes the superclass was animal and the dog class extended the animal class having a fetch method of its own, but when I referenced the dog variable as animal it did not work here is the code … The error tester.java:4: error: cannot find symbol doggie.fetch(); symbol: method fetch() location: variable doggie of type animal When using polymorphism, if you create an instance of the subclass and store its reference in a variable of superclass type, you can only call those methods on the newly created instance which are present in the super class. In your code, you created an instance of dog class and stored its reference in doggie which is of type animal (super class of dog), In such case, you can't call any method on dog class instance that isn't available in animal class. fetch method is not defined in the animal class hence you get the error. Either define the fetch method in the animal class OR Change animal doggie = new dog(); to dog doggie = new dog(); Developer’s Goal Developer’s Pertinent Action System Symptom Accepted Answer Symptom Cause Posted Solution Solution Justification RQ2 Findings: Developer Focus
  • 6. • Too much text including unnecessary details (69%) • Determining embedded code segment relevance (51%) • Too much code including unnecessary details (39%) Developer’s Goal Developer’s Pertinent Action System Symptom Symptom Cause Posted Solution Solution Justification Novice software engineers pay attention to only 27% code and 15-21% of text in a SO post! @PreethaChatterj [email protected] sites.udel.edu/preethac/ Significance:  improve the Q&A forum interface  guide tools for mining forums  improve granularity of traceability mappings involving forum posts Paper link: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2019.110454 Summary and Overview RQ1. Challenges - What slows a novice software engineer down in identifying the solution most appropriate for their problem? RQ2. Focus - Which parts of a post novice software engineers focus on to reduce their time in locating information?

Editor's Notes

  • #3: The recent Stack Overflow survey shows that 40% participants are novice programmers i.e. people with less than 5 years of coding experience. SO often contain long threads of discussions. A previous study suggests that reading answers of a popular SO post could take about 30 minutes!! Because of this information overload, Finding help from SO is especially difficult for novice software engineers. We conducted an exploratory study to understand how novice software engineers direct their efforts and what kinds of information they focus on within a post.
  • #4: Specifically, our exploratory case study answers 2 research questions: To answer RQ1, we conducted a survey to gather novice software engineers’ perceptions of what slows them down in their Stack Overflow usage. For (RQ2) the software engineers first annotated 400 Stack Overflow posts to indicate what they would recommend to highlight to focus attention. Then, we analyzed their annotations, to gain more insight into their recommendations.
  • #5: Findings from RQ1 suggest that, majority of participants indicated the obstacles of “Too much text containing unnecessary details”, followed by “Determining embedded code segment relevance”, and “Too much code containing unnecessary details”.
  • #6: The results from RQ2 discern the kinds of information prominent in the developers’ focus. In the question we find the: Developers’ Goal: or their intended outcome. Developer’s Pertinent Action: that led to the error. Observed system response to the developer’s action. In the answer we find the: cause of the error. Suggested approach to fix the error. Reason why the suggested Solution works.
  • #7: The results from this study can be leveraged to guide tools for mining forums, and improve granularity of traceability mappings involving forum posts.